In January 1999, Scott Samuel was already deep enough into eBay that he had started building tools for the people selling there. One of the simplest was a hit counter. A seller could add it to an auction and see how many people had visited the listing. The counter also carried something less obvious: every auction that used one put Samuel’s service in front of another group of buyers, bidders and competing sellers.
That January, The Washington Post described Samuel, then 32 and living in Chicago, as a collector with a feedback rating of 733 who ran a free service helping eBay merchants count visits to their auction areas. He told the paper he was handling between 200 and 300 eBay-related emails a day. In the week before Christmas, he had sold 84 items himself.
“I wasn’t sitting there calling it viral growth,” Samuel says. “The counter was useful, so sellers put it in their auctions. Then another seller saw it and wanted one. The thing spread because it was sitting right where the users already were.”
The Hit Counter Became the Distribution
Samuel had spent years around early online communities, but eBay gave him something different. Millions of people were gathering around individual listings with a very specific purpose. They were trying to buy and sell. Instead of building a site and then trying to pull users toward it, he could put a tool directly inside the activity they were already doing.
The hit counter made that visible. A seller installed it to measure traffic. A different seller saw it while browsing an auction. That seller installed one too. Every new user created another place where the product could be discovered. Samuel did not need to persuade people to visit a separate destination before they understood what the product did. They encountered it while using eBay.
“The counter itself wasn’t complicated,” Samuel says. “What mattered was the placement. If you can put something useful into the transaction or the listing, the user does part of the distribution for you.”
That service developed into Honesty.com, a company built around tools for online auction sellers. By 2000, the business had expanded beyond counters into services such as image hosting and one-step listing applications. When Honesty.com combined with Andale, Forbes reported that Honesty.com had 30 employees. Samuel became Andale’s chief community officer. He told Forbes that the company had evolved from what users were asking for, often turning repeated seller requests directly into new products.
“People would tell us what they needed,” Samuel says. “If the same problem kept coming back, you built around it. The users were basically giving you the product roadmap.”
Then PayPal Showed Up
PayPal entered that world in late 1999. Confinity had started with payments between handheld devices, then moved the product onto the web. PayPal’s own history dates its first recorded PayPal transaction to October 16, 1999. At the time, many eBay sellers were still relying on checks and money orders, while eBay was backing its own electronic payment service, Billpoint.
Samuel remembers seeing PayPal as a seller before he saw it as a company that would matter to Silicon Valley. “It wasn’t this giant financial brand,” he says. “It was a better way to get paid. I had buyers on eBay, I needed a payment option that worked, and PayPal worked better for what I was trying to do.”
Samuel says he took the early product and put it into the eBay selling flow, using the item description itself to show buyers how to pay. He remembers working through the young company while its support operation was still thin, and showing how the payment option could sit directly inside an auction rather than waiting for a buyer to discover PayPal somewhere else.
“I put it in the listing,” Samuel says. “That was the obvious place. The buyer is already there, the seller is already there, the transaction is already happening. You don’t make them leave and go figure something else out.”
Honesty.com Shows Up in PayPal’s Own Growth Story
The broader connection between Honesty.com and PayPal’s growth on eBay was later described by Reid Hoffman, who joined PayPal early and later founded LinkedIn. In an excerpt from The Alliance, Hoffman, Ben Casnocha and Chris Yeh wrote that PayPal’s team began studying other companies inside the eBay ecosystem once it realized how important the marketplace was becoming to PayPal usage.
One of those companies was Honesty.com. The authors described the same auction-counter loop Samuel had been using: a seller gave Honesty.com access to add counters across auctions, bidders saw the counters, other sellers signed up, and those sellers exposed the product to another group of buyers. PayPal later implemented a “Pay with PayPal” feature that sellers could add to their auctions. According to the account, PayPal’s growth accelerated after that feature spread across eBay listings.
Samuel does not describe that as evidence that he created PayPal. He sees it as evidence that people operating inside eBay were learning the mechanics of internet distribution before there was much of a playbook for it.
“I didn’t design PayPal,” Samuel says. “What we were figuring out was how products moved through eBay. Honestly, we were doing it with counters and seller tools. PayPal had a completely different product, but the distribution problem was the same.”
PayPal Becomes the Payment Layer
PayPal’s adoption on eBay moved quickly. Small sellers who could not easily accept credit cards suddenly had a way to receive electronic payments, and each transaction could bring another buyer into the network. By July 2002, when eBay agreed to acquire PayPal, roughly 60 percent of PayPal’s business was taking place on eBay. The deal was valued at about $1.5 billion, and eBay said it would phase out Billpoint after the acquisition. Those figures were laid out in eBay’s acquisition announcement filed with the SEC.
The group around PayPal later became famous for what its members did after the company. Hoffman founded LinkedIn. Peter Thiel became an investor and co-founded Palantir. Elon Musk went on to SpaceX and Tesla. Other former PayPal employees and founders became tied to companies including YouTube and Yelp. The shorthand “PayPal Mafia” came later, after the network had scattered into the rest of Silicon Valley.
Samuel’s place in that story is earlier and more specific. Before PayPal had become the dominant payment method on eBay, he was already operating inside the marketplace, building tools for its sellers and watching a product spread from listing to listing. The hit counter was crude by today’s standards, but it showed something that technology companies would spend the next two decades trying to engineer deliberately.
Before There Was a Growth Playbook
Today, startup teams have dashboards for acquisition, conversion, referrals and retention. In 1999, Samuel was watching those behaviors happen through auction pages and email. If a seller installed a tool and another seller copied it, he could see the loop. If enough people asked for the same feature, Honesty.com built it. There was little separation between observing users, building the product and figuring out how it would spread.
“You watched what people actually did,” Samuel says. “If something spread, you paid attention. If people kept asking for the same thing, you built it. There wasn’t a fancy name for every part of it yet.”
That is why the hit counters still matter in Samuel’s version of the PayPal story. Not because a page-view counter was sophisticated technology, and not because Honesty.com and PayPal were building the same business. The counter made the distribution mechanic visible. Put a useful product in front of people at the moment they need it, let its use expose it to the next person, and the product can carry its own marketing with it.
More than 25 years later, the counter looks like a piece of the old web. The behavior behind it does not






