By: Natalie Johnson
Every large employer runs an engagement survey, and most of them have nothing to show for it. The ritual is familiar: a questionnaire in the spring, a deck in the summer, a town hall where someone presents color-coded charts, then silence until the following spring. Nancy D. Adams, who works with leaders on organizational culture in healthcare, argues that the problem is not the instrument. It is that listening has been treated as an annual event rather than a management discipline, and employees have learned to read the difference. Her case is blunt and it carries a price tag: in healthcare, where margins are thin and talent is scarce, the gap between the appearance of listening and the real thing shows up directly in turnover costs and in operational waste that nobody upstream can see.
Listening As A Habit, Not A Calendar Entry
Adams reframes the entire exercise. “It looks like a habit, not an event,” she says. “An annual survey is a snapshot, but culture moves every day.” What replaces the snapshot is unglamorous and repeatable. Managers ask one real question in every one-on-one: what’s getting in your way? Senior leaders sit down with people two or three levels below them, with no slides. Organizations also hold stay interviews with their strongest performers to learn why they stay and what would push them out. Her distinction between stay and exit interviews deserves to be read as an indictment of standard practice. “Exit interviews are autopsies. Stay interviews are checkups.” Most companies invest heavily in the autopsy and skip the checkup entirely, which is a strange way to manage an asset you claim is your most valuable.
The harder skill is reading what is not said. Leaders tend to interpret quiet teams as content teams, and Adams flatly rejects that. “Then pay attention to the silence,” she says. “Silence usually means people stopped believing it matters.” That is a diagnostic worth sitting with. Disengagement does not announce itself. It presents as cooperation, as meetings that end on time, as feedback channels that go quiet because the people who used them learned that nothing followed. By the time silence is obvious, the behavior that produced it has usually been rewarded for years.
The Three Ways Leaders Fake It
Adams identifies the counterfeits with precision, and all three are well regarded in most organizations. The first is the survey that goes nowhere. “Employees aren’t tired of surveys. They’re tired of surveys that lead nowhere,” she says, which should trouble any executive who has concluded their workforce suffers from survey fatigue. The second is the open-door policy, a cherished item in leadership self-description. “An open door waits for the brave few to walk through it. Real listening means walking out your door.” The asymmetry is the point. An open door puts the risk on the employee and the convenience on the executive, then counts the resulting trickle of visitors as evidence of accessibility.
The third is the most damaging because it happens inside conversations leaders believe are going well. “The biggest one is ‘Yes, but,'” Adams says. “The moment a leader starts defending, the conversation is over. People may keep talking, but they’ve stopped telling the truth.” Anyone who has sat in a skip-level meeting that turned into an explanation of why the current approach is correct has watched this happen in real time. Adams adds a structural caution on top of the behavioral one. “If you only listen to those at headquarters, in English, during business hours, you’re missing key parts of your company.” In healthcare in particular, where the night shift, the satellite sites, and non-English-speaking staff carry enormous operational load, that filter is not a minor sampling error. It systematically excludes the people closest to the work.
Why The Cost Case Is Stronger Than The Culture Case
Listening is usually sold as a soft good, which is precisely why it loses budget fights. Adams prefers to argue it on the ledger. “Turnover is one of the biggest costs in healthcare, and it rarely gets its own line in the budget,” she says, putting the average cost of losing a single bedside nurse at about $50,000. The arithmetic she runs is simple enough to survive a finance review: in a system with 500 nurses, retaining just 15 more a year is worth roughly $750,000. That number is not a projection of improved morale. It is cost avoidance on a line item most organizations absorb without naming.
The second half of the financial case is the one leaders tend to miss entirely. “Your frontline staff know exactly where the waste is,” Adams says. “Some of the best cost-cutting consultants you’ll ever have are already on your payroll, and most organizations never ask them.” Converting that knowledge into credibility requires discipline about what happens after the feedback arrives. Adams tells leaders to treat it like a complaint from their biggest customer: fast, specific, and owned. Share results within 30 days. Be honest about what cannot be done and why, since “a clear no builds more trust than a vague maybe.” Then say the connection out loud: we changed this because you told us that. Her test for whether any of it is real is uncomfortable by design. Ask a leader to name three things they changed last year because of employee feedback. If they cannot, they are not listening. The same standard will decide who benefits from AI-driven sentiment tools. “AI will make good cultures better and bad cultures worse,” Adams says. “In a high-trust company, it feels like being heard at scale. In a low-trust company, it feels like being watched.” Her guidance is to build three things before buying anything: a clear promise about what is collected, what never is, and who sees it; managers capable of acting on what the data surfaces, because AI will find problems faster than most companies can fix them; and human judgment, because AI sees patterns, not context, and someone still has to go and ask. “Listening technology will soon be cheap and everywhere. Trust won’t be. That’s where the real advantage will live.”
Follow Nancy D. Adams on LinkedIn for more insights on organizational culture, employee listening, and talent retention in healthcare.






