Skip to main content

CEO Weekly

Carole Lawson of MarketStorm, Traffic Won’t Win the Next Decade, Influence Will

Carole Lawson of MarketStorm, Traffic Won't Win the Next Decade, Influence Will
Photo Courtesy: Carole Lawson

By: Eva Keller

A homeowner has trusted Joe’s Plumbing for years. But over the past few weeks, she keeps running into Speedy Plumbing everywhere she goes online. Then a pipe bursts. She types Joe’s name into Google, and Google shows her Speedy.

Carole Lawson, co-founder and Chief Data Officer of MarketStorm, uses that scenario to explain where marketing is heading. “You might still search for Joe’s Plumbing, but guess what Google’s going to put in front of you? Speedy,” Lawson says. “Because the AI is learning that your loyalty is changing and you may be open to another service provider that better meets your exact needs.”

In other words, the click your dashboard celebrates is often just the final step of a decision that was made somewhere else. Put another way, Paid search is largely a collection system, not a growth system. Search marketing tends to convert demand that other media and marketing created, and the attribution models most brands rely on systematically reward the harvester for the crop while starving the field.

Most companies still treat their website as the destination and traffic as the scoreboard. Lawson believes that model is quickly eroding. “Traffic itself is not going to win the day,” she says. “Influence is going to win the day, because influence is a business growth driver.” In her view, an AI answer that mentions a brand without earning a click still counts as a win. “There’s a fallacy that a click is a win. A click is one kind of a win. But what really matters more than clicks is a change in preference that has been influenced before the click.”

Loyalty Has Gone Soft

The numbers show why this matters now. Three years ago, research found that putting a brand in front of a buyer at the right moment could change that buyer’s mind about 49% of the time. Today, “it’s up to 70%.” Loyalty has gone soft, and the conversations shaping it are happening in ChatGPT, Gemini, and Reddit.

Lawson breaks this into two layers. The influence layer is where intent forms, preferences shift, and demand is created. The demand capture layer, which is still mostly Google, is where people act on a decision they’ve already half-made. Most marketing budgets fight over the demand capture layer, but the influence layer is where the outcome actually gets decided, and how sustained business growth can be achieved.

The brutal truth is that a brand that ignores the influence layer will have a weak capture layer and will overpay for clicks, forever. The result is stagnated sales and a higher cost per acquisition.

What AI Believes About You Matters

Winning in the influence layer depends on something few teams actively manage: what AI believes about you.

Your website, business profile, partner case studies, and Reddit threads all get merged into a single entity in AI’s eyes. “One of the easiest ways to get AI to start hallucinating about you is to not have the same story told across every entity,” she says. Or, put more bluntly: “If there’s not consistency, the AI is going to pass over it, and you’ll never be cited.”

That’s the new prize. Not a visit, but a citation. And chasing site visits exposes habits that many companies still consider best practice. Keyword-stuffed pages read like gibberish to AI, Lawson says, because it “can’t pull back full thoughts.” White papers locked behind forms may be completely invisible: “If you have gated content and you are gating also the bots that are reviewing it, that gated content does not exist.” And content mass-produced with the same AI tools everyone else uses ends up cancelling itself out. “Your blog is going to sound just like their blog because you’re using the same tools,” Lawson says. Her co-founder Rick Brown calls it a sea of sameness.

How to Earn Influence and Prove It

The way out is specificity. Bob shouldn’t publish another “plumber near me” page. He should explain sewer replacements and fixture work, and why each job matters, until he becomes a source instead of a listing.

Measurement has to change, too. Search is where influence gets recorded. It is rarely where influence is made. If influence is the goal, the proof is more people looking for you by name. “We want to see more searches for the brand itself,” she says, along with a lower combined cost per acquisition across all spend.

Five Things CEOs Need to Do Now to Grow Their Brand in the Age of AI

1. Find buyers while intent is still forming. Most budgets fight over people who have already half decided. Real-time behavioral signals reveal who is starting to look upstream, where brands can shape the decision instead of competing for it.

2. Show up where decisions are shaped, not just where they’re finalized. With the right brand at the right moment now changing buyers’ minds up to 70% of the time, coordinated touchpoints across AI assistants, Reddit, and the wider digital environment build preference before anyone searches.

3. Tell one consistent story everywhere. AI merges every source about your company into one picture, and inconsistencies get you ignored or misrepresented. Ask Gemini what it knows about you, then fix every place where your website, profiles, and executives’ posts tell different stories.

4. Become a source, not a listing. Generic and AI-generated content disappears into the sea of sameness, while specific, expert content gets cited. Open gated assets to AI crawlers so they actually exist.

5. Measure influence, not just traffic. Track branded search, AI citations, and blended cost per acquisition. Instead of asking your marketing team how much traffic you got, ask how many more people asked for you by name.

The companies that win the next decade won’t be the ones with the most visitors. They’ll be the ones AI trusts enough to repeat.

Spread the love

Apply now at fundivi before your busy season catches you unprepared.

ceo weekly contributor

This article features branded content from a third party. Opinions in this article do not reflect the opinions and beliefs of CEO Weekly.

CEO Weekly

HOT TOPICS